Nazir v. City of Torrance (2014) – Obtained summary judgment against an officer who was terminated for being placed on the Brady list in a case alleging violations of the officer’s First Amendment rights.
Summary Judgement Win On USERRA Claim (2011) – Represented the City in a discrimination suit. Plaintiff alleged the City discriminated against him by violating the federal military leave law, USERRA. Summary judgment granted in favor of City. Plaintiff’s cross-motion for summary judgment denied. The court correctly determined that USERRA does not entitle an employee while on leave to automatically receive promotions or pay increases which are generally based on merit. The court distinguished job advancement based solely on seniority as opposed to merit. With pure seniority, the employee receives promotion and pay increases “automatically” while on leave.
Batts et al. v. City of Los Angeles, et al. (2010) – Successfully defended the City of Los Angeles, the Los Angeles Police Department, Chief William Bratton, and other high-level Police Department command staff in a retaliation action brought by nine police department sergeants who alleged they had suffered adverse employment actions because of their participation in a wage and hour litigation against the City. The alleged adverse actions included disciplinary investigations, relief from duty, suspension, transfer, and denial of promotion. Plaintiffs attempted to bring the matter as a class action, but the Court dismissed the class allegations. Following depositions of each Plaintiff, of Chief Bratton, and some individual defendants, LCW brought nine summary judgment motions, one for each Plaintiff. The Court granted all the motions, resulting in a defense victory on all claims.
Tackett v. County of Imperial (2007) – Summary judgment was awarded in this lawsuit brought by a Sheriff Deputy claiming retaliation and race discrimination.
Ho v. City of Azusa (2007) – Obtained a summary judgment on behalf of the city in this case brought by the union president alleging first amendment retaliation.
Bohacik v. City of Hermosa Beach (2006) – Obtained summary judgment in favor of the City in this Public Safety Officers’ Procedural Bill of Rights Act case involving internal affairs investigation.
Lewitt v. City of Hermosa Beach (2006) – Successful in obtaining a summary judgment in this law enforcement investigation case.
Ware v. City of Pasadena and Chief Bernard Melekian (2004) – Wrongful termination and Freedom of Speech case in a Federal Court jury trial. We won a defense verdict on the wrongful termination claim and, based on the juror’s answers to proposed questions, the Judge held that the balance was in favor of the City on the freedom of speech claim. The Judge granted a motion for judgment as a matter of law on all of the claims on behalf of the Defendants.